General Gallant, no doubt your letter will be opened but it remains to be seen whether the mullahs will wake up from their dream of a military nuclear weapon. I hope they will wake up from that dream and decide to join the society of nations that puts their own civilian populations before the support of terror proxies. "Fortunately for us, the Mediterranean lies to the west".
As an Iranian I promise these creatures dont understand human languages. Just look what are they doing with our ppl in Iran while they are living by our goods & taxes. So its wrong talk & negotiate with them. Crying is their strategy. Finish them & world will be free.
I think Khamenei himself couldn't put his situation together up to now. This letter helps him to get a better vision to the mess he is in!
The lost element that wasn't mentioned in the general's letter is the Iranian people. They should take their destiny in their own hands and get rid of the notorious mullahs as soon as possible to lessen the damage to our long-suffering country.
Excellent letter General Gallant. The mission in Iran has made all of us Diaspora jews so proud. I just hope that we are now focussing on arming, equipping, training and funding the dissident insurrectionists within Iran so that that they take their country back once and for all.
I was expecting such a letter — but not from you. I expected it from your commander, Netanyahu — and not this soon, nor with such a shaky and worthless tone.
That letter of yours merely declared, through a patchwork of Don Quixote-style bravado, your fear and panic at the nearing end of a flimsy, short-lived, counterfeit country.
With my experience in psychology, I was absolutely certain that your cowardly commander would write something — not out of strength, but to satisfy his diseased mind and suppress his fear.
Just like your distorted book says: even the sound of a falling leaf behind you will terrify you — and now, that sound has only grown louder.
It is because of this deep-seated fear that you resort to assassination and terror. Your hollow "power" lacks the courage for face-to-face combat like real warriors. So instead, you strike like prostitutes with hidden daggers — attacking and assassinating without declaring war, just to avoid a direct and honorable fight.
Ah, you were once called a "Minister of War" — but does a regime built on terror even need a Minister of War?
You couldn’t even defeat a few unarmed civilians in Gaza, even with your most advanced technology — which you yourself proudly admit to possessing — even with F-35 jets bombing refugee tents, you still failed to claim victory. So how on earth do you expect to overcome Iran — the mighty lion of this region?
With your childish nighttime assassinations and your slaughter of innocent people and children, all you’ve done is shorten your own lifespan.
I was waiting for the Don Quixote of Zionism to dress up his humiliation as “victory,” even as he begged the surrounding countries — and Trump — to tell Iran: Please don’t turn occupied Palestine into more of a hell than it already is. Please don’t end Zionism before the date engraved in Palestine Square in Tehran. Please agree to a ceasefire.
I was waiting for it.
And thank God, my prediction was right.
Most of your time is gone, and now just a few short years remain — so this letter of yours was entirely predictable.
After your spies embedded in the high ranks of the Islamic system are executed, we will cast you to the soil and the sea. And then — just when you sit down with an Arab, a Turk, a Kurd, or a Westerner to plot another assassination — you will simply disappear.
Unless, by the time we arrive, you’ve already fled to your den from 70 years ago.
This is a guaranteed promise — clearly mentioned in the Holy Qur’an, in Surahs Al-Fil and Quraysh.
You are the companions of the elephant, and we — the nations of this region — are the Quraysh.
Since you wrote respectfully, I will consider you respectful as well; General Gallant, In a part of your pompous letter, you wrote, “Hope is not a strategy.” You should know that while hope may not be a strategy, faith is a strategy. Faith in the presence of God, Faith that the oppressor will never see happiness! The Iranian nation, under the leadership of Seyyed Ali Khamenei (may his shadow endure), believes that Israel is an illegitimate child, which, as the President of Germany said, has come only to do the dirty work of the superpowers! Without America, you are nothing! And even with it, you are still nothing! Seyyed Ali Khamenei, the leader who, despite unprecedented sanctions, with this very strategy (faith), within his capacity, rubbed your nose in the dirt with missiles. This leader is a source of pride for me. Know that you take pride in killing us, While we take pride in martyrdom, even at the hands of the filthiest kind of human.
Read some history: the US had an arms embargo against Israel from 1948 to 1968. Didn't stop Israel achieving a spectacular victory in the 1967 Six Day War. Is that nothing?
Here is the capacity of your little ayatollah (actually hojatoleslam, he was never able to achieve ayatollah rank through his studies):
General Gallant, I wonder if there is a similar letter to be written to the Israeli people.
As a diaspora Jew I sleep more soundly every night knowing my family have a place to go where Jews can both defend themselves in the most modern ways possible and still maintain daily an ancient but practical covenant with G-d based on responsibility and service rather than superiority over others. In this moment of triumph, will the Jewish state bask in its newfound military glory or draw on the wisdom of its traditions?
The ring of fire, for all its failures and naked exploitation of the plight of Palestinian Arabs, nonetheless showed that the Palestinian issue is Israel’s greatest vulnerability, culturally as well as militarily. Will Israel show the strength to deepen economic and social integration with its nearly two million Arab citizens - who stood by it in this moment of risk? Will it begin to not just consider, but implement new models of governance that maintain the premise of Jewish statehood while giving the non-Jewish minority a distinct voice in local and national affairs? Can it begin to create with local allies a similar infrastructure in Gaza and the West Bank?
Now, as ever, forces external and internal to Palestine will take every opportunity to undermine. But these forces are weaker today than they have been. Now, as ever, the “international community” will ridicule. But its fecklessness has been exposed like never before.
Of course Israel must gird itself for Iran’s next round (or for the next power ready to exploit Palestinians for its own purposes). But can it also invest heavily in multiple paths not just to coexistence but to a bright future together?
You are certainly correct in suggesting that as non-citizens we must be very humble in our convictions regarding Israel’s domestic politics. If my comment came off as anything other than that, I apologize. I was attempting to solicit General Gallant’s and this community’s views on how recent victories might be leveraged to strengthen the bond that has been built between Israel’s Jewish and Arab citizens, and perhaps even to imagine how (if it all) it could be exported to the situation of the territories. If Iran and its proxies thought the relationship between Israel’s Jews and Arabs was a vulnerability, they were proven very wrong. The relationship not only survived the difficult choices made in Gaza, but also seemed to be a genuine strategic asset in Israel’s defense. If so, is there an opportunity to nurture this asset further?
"maintain the premise of Jewish statehood while giving the non-Jewish minority a distinct voice in local and national affairs"
Like having two Israeli Arabs attain the rank of Major-General in the IDF? Like Brig Gen Hisham Ibrahim, forner Commander of the IDF Armored Corps?
Like Professor Hossam Haick, Dean of Undergraduates at the Technion?
Like Dr Samer Haj Yehya, Executive Chairman of Bank Leumi, Israel's largest?
Like Khaled Khabub, Justice on Israel's Supreme Court?
Maybe there's no worthwhile advice to hear from Diaspora Jews like you and me and a letter from Gen Gallant to us would make more sense?
Evidently one does not need to live on the Gaza border to swallow hook, line and sinker every slander uttered by the enemies of Israel. Remember October 8th as well!
The only thing clear is that the ayatollahs are much weaker than believed. Were their Russian friends helpful or are they cutting a deal with Trump that will leave the Islamic Republic behind?
This shows the primitive mentality of the ayatollahs, fighting against one of the greatest technological powers of our time:
Brilliant.
General Gallant, no doubt your letter will be opened but it remains to be seen whether the mullahs will wake up from their dream of a military nuclear weapon. I hope they will wake up from that dream and decide to join the society of nations that puts their own civilian populations before the support of terror proxies. "Fortunately for us, the Mediterranean lies to the west".
As an Iranian I promise these creatures dont understand human languages. Just look what are they doing with our ppl in Iran while they are living by our goods & taxes. So its wrong talk & negotiate with them. Crying is their strategy. Finish them & world will be free.
You’re not Iranian
An honor to read a letter of that importance. Time will tell if the Ayatollah adjusts his priorities.
I think Khamenei himself couldn't put his situation together up to now. This letter helps him to get a better vision to the mess he is in!
The lost element that wasn't mentioned in the general's letter is the Iranian people. They should take their destiny in their own hands and get rid of the notorious mullahs as soon as possible to lessen the damage to our long-suffering country.
"Speak softly and carry a big stick." -Teddy Roosevelt
“First comes strength. Then comes peace.” -Benjamin Netanyahu
Excellent letter General Gallant. The mission in Iran has made all of us Diaspora jews so proud. I just hope that we are now focussing on arming, equipping, training and funding the dissident insurrectionists within Iran so that that they take their country back once and for all.
Brilliant
I was expecting such a letter — but not from you. I expected it from your commander, Netanyahu — and not this soon, nor with such a shaky and worthless tone.
That letter of yours merely declared, through a patchwork of Don Quixote-style bravado, your fear and panic at the nearing end of a flimsy, short-lived, counterfeit country.
With my experience in psychology, I was absolutely certain that your cowardly commander would write something — not out of strength, but to satisfy his diseased mind and suppress his fear.
Just like your distorted book says: even the sound of a falling leaf behind you will terrify you — and now, that sound has only grown louder.
It is because of this deep-seated fear that you resort to assassination and terror. Your hollow "power" lacks the courage for face-to-face combat like real warriors. So instead, you strike like prostitutes with hidden daggers — attacking and assassinating without declaring war, just to avoid a direct and honorable fight.
Ah, you were once called a "Minister of War" — but does a regime built on terror even need a Minister of War?
You couldn’t even defeat a few unarmed civilians in Gaza, even with your most advanced technology — which you yourself proudly admit to possessing — even with F-35 jets bombing refugee tents, you still failed to claim victory. So how on earth do you expect to overcome Iran — the mighty lion of this region?
With your childish nighttime assassinations and your slaughter of innocent people and children, all you’ve done is shorten your own lifespan.
I was waiting for the Don Quixote of Zionism to dress up his humiliation as “victory,” even as he begged the surrounding countries — and Trump — to tell Iran: Please don’t turn occupied Palestine into more of a hell than it already is. Please don’t end Zionism before the date engraved in Palestine Square in Tehran. Please agree to a ceasefire.
I was waiting for it.
And thank God, my prediction was right.
Most of your time is gone, and now just a few short years remain — so this letter of yours was entirely predictable.
After your spies embedded in the high ranks of the Islamic system are executed, we will cast you to the soil and the sea. And then — just when you sit down with an Arab, a Turk, a Kurd, or a Westerner to plot another assassination — you will simply disappear.
Unless, by the time we arrive, you’ve already fled to your den from 70 years ago.
This is a guaranteed promise — clearly mentioned in the Holy Qur’an, in Surahs Al-Fil and Quraysh.
You are the companions of the elephant, and we — the nations of this region — are the Quraysh.
.
Who are you exactly? Fired as defence minister, wanted by the ICC, resorting to chatgpt to write on sub stack. Pathetic.
Since you wrote respectfully, I will consider you respectful as well; General Gallant, In a part of your pompous letter, you wrote, “Hope is not a strategy.” You should know that while hope may not be a strategy, faith is a strategy. Faith in the presence of God, Faith that the oppressor will never see happiness! The Iranian nation, under the leadership of Seyyed Ali Khamenei (may his shadow endure), believes that Israel is an illegitimate child, which, as the President of Germany said, has come only to do the dirty work of the superpowers! Without America, you are nothing! And even with it, you are still nothing! Seyyed Ali Khamenei, the leader who, despite unprecedented sanctions, with this very strategy (faith), within his capacity, rubbed your nose in the dirt with missiles. This leader is a source of pride for me. Know that you take pride in killing us, While we take pride in martyrdom, even at the hands of the filthiest kind of human.
Read some history: the US had an arms embargo against Israel from 1948 to 1968. Didn't stop Israel achieving a spectacular victory in the 1967 Six Day War. Is that nothing?
Here is the capacity of your little ayatollah (actually hojatoleslam, he was never able to achieve ayatollah rank through his studies):
https://nkowsar.substack.com/p/did-mossad-really-deploy-genies-against
Is this silliness really a source of pride for you? Shah Reza and his White Revolution are the real pride of modern Iran.
General Gallant, I wonder if there is a similar letter to be written to the Israeli people.
As a diaspora Jew I sleep more soundly every night knowing my family have a place to go where Jews can both defend themselves in the most modern ways possible and still maintain daily an ancient but practical covenant with G-d based on responsibility and service rather than superiority over others. In this moment of triumph, will the Jewish state bask in its newfound military glory or draw on the wisdom of its traditions?
The ring of fire, for all its failures and naked exploitation of the plight of Palestinian Arabs, nonetheless showed that the Palestinian issue is Israel’s greatest vulnerability, culturally as well as militarily. Will Israel show the strength to deepen economic and social integration with its nearly two million Arab citizens - who stood by it in this moment of risk? Will it begin to not just consider, but implement new models of governance that maintain the premise of Jewish statehood while giving the non-Jewish minority a distinct voice in local and national affairs? Can it begin to create with local allies a similar infrastructure in Gaza and the West Bank?
Now, as ever, forces external and internal to Palestine will take every opportunity to undermine. But these forces are weaker today than they have been. Now, as ever, the “international community” will ridicule. But its fecklessness has been exposed like never before.
Of course Israel must gird itself for Iran’s next round (or for the next power ready to exploit Palestinians for its own purposes). But can it also invest heavily in multiple paths not just to coexistence but to a bright future together?
You are certainly correct in suggesting that as non-citizens we must be very humble in our convictions regarding Israel’s domestic politics. If my comment came off as anything other than that, I apologize. I was attempting to solicit General Gallant’s and this community’s views on how recent victories might be leveraged to strengthen the bond that has been built between Israel’s Jewish and Arab citizens, and perhaps even to imagine how (if it all) it could be exported to the situation of the territories. If Iran and its proxies thought the relationship between Israel’s Jews and Arabs was a vulnerability, they were proven very wrong. The relationship not only survived the difficult choices made in Gaza, but also seemed to be a genuine strategic asset in Israel’s defense. If so, is there an opportunity to nurture this asset further?
"maintain the premise of Jewish statehood while giving the non-Jewish minority a distinct voice in local and national affairs"
Like having two Israeli Arabs attain the rank of Major-General in the IDF? Like Brig Gen Hisham Ibrahim, forner Commander of the IDF Armored Corps?
Like Professor Hossam Haick, Dean of Undergraduates at the Technion?
Like Dr Samer Haj Yehya, Executive Chairman of Bank Leumi, Israel's largest?
Like Khaled Khabub, Justice on Israel's Supreme Court?
Maybe there's no worthwhile advice to hear from Diaspora Jews like you and me and a letter from Gen Gallant to us would make more sense?
Evidently one does not need to live on the Gaza border to swallow hook, line and sinker every slander uttered by the enemies of Israel. Remember October 8th as well!
کاملا معلومه که اسرائیل به نابودی نزدیک شده و چیزی به پایانش باقی نمانده و طاقت دیدن پیروزی ایران را ندارد
این حرفها همگی از دستپاچگی رژیم غاصب است
رژیم کودک کش به پایان سلام کن😄
The only thing clear is that the ayatollahs are much weaker than believed. Were their Russian friends helpful or are they cutting a deal with Trump that will leave the Islamic Republic behind?
This shows the primitive mentality of the ayatollahs, fighting against one of the greatest technological powers of our time:
https://nkowsar.substack.com/p/did-mossad-really-deploy-genies-against
😆💪🇮🇱🇺🇲
💥 🫡 But let’s not mince words…Israel knows everything and Iran is on notice. General Gallant, thank you for your service! 🇮🇱
Shkoyach
Couldn't be more direct and complete. Brilliant!